Warm, familiar, and straight from grandma’s kitchen—our chocolate chunk cookies bring back the simple joy of after-school treats and a cold glass of milk waiting on the table. Baked with wholesome, simple ingredients, each bite is soft, rich, and comforting, with melty chocolate chunks tucked into a golden, freshly baked cookie that fills the air with that unmistakable homemade aroma.

Soft, hearty, and full of old-fashioned charm—these oatmeal cream pies bring you back to childhood lunchboxes and quiet afternoons by your favorite fishing hole. Made with simple, real ingredients, the cookies are tender with just the right touch of spice, sandwiched around a smooth, creamy filling. A comforting, familiar treat that feels like slowing down and savoring the moment.

Simple, wholesome, and made the old-fashioned way—this yeast sandwich loaf is the kind of bread that belongs on every kitchen counter. Soft and tender with a gentle crumb, yet sturdy enough to hold up to a generous spread of peanut butter and jelly without tearing. Made with real, simple ingredients, it’s everyday bread just like you remember—perfect for sandwiches, toast, and everything in between.

Soft, nostalgic, and warmly familiar—this snickerdoodle takes you straight back to the simple joy of early school days, when a cinnamon-sugar treat could make everything better. Baked with the same care and wholesome ingredients that define my kitchen, each cookie is tender, comforting, and just the right amount of sweet. And for a little twist? It’s gently stuffed with a rich blend of brown sugar, cinnamon, and butter—like a hidden hug in every bite.

A classic snickerdoodle, kicked up a notch. Soft and chewy with that familiar cinnamon-sugar coating, then stuffed with a rich brown sugar cinnamon filling. All the cozy flavor you remember from childhood—just a little more indulgent.

Soft vanilla sugar cookies sandwiched with a fluffy vanilla cream filling. Simple, nostalgic, and reminiscent of the homemade treats cooling on grandma’s kitchen counter.

Deep, rich, and made for the true chocolate lover—our triple chocolate crinkle cookies are pure indulgence in every bite. Crafted with simple, wholesome ingredients, they’re soft and fudgy with a delicate crackled top, delivering layer after layer of chocolate flavor that satisfies even the strongest craving. A cozy, bakery-fresh treat that feels just a little extra special.

Warm and familiar, this peanut butter cookie brings back the simple comfort of after-school treats and lunchbox favorites. Made with wholesome, real ingredients and baked with care, it’s soft, rich, and perfectly nostalgic—just like you remember. A timeless classic that feels like home in every bite.

Choose up to 4 flavors to create your own custom box of 12 cookies. Not currently available for the 6 cookie box.